"Benji 'n' Reggie, Benji 'n' Reggie," people say in a “singsong way” (Whitehead 2). For much of their lives, the Sag Harbor gang thought of Benji and Reggie Cooper as not two people, but rather “the twins” (even separated by ten months). They’re referred to together, and treated as two parts of one item. I think that part of Sag Harbor tells the story of how Benji decides to differentiate himself and become independent. Colson Whitehead's Sag Harbor opens with a summer: the kind that feels infinite while in youth, yet once you blink it’s over. By the summer the novel takes place, puberty has struck both of the siblings, sending Benji "up and airborne, tall and skinny, a knock-kneed little reed, while Reggie, always chubby in the cheeks and arms, bulged out into something round and pinch-able."(Whitehead 4) My brother and I, also nine months apart, looked very similar for quite a while. And similarly, as we got older, those physical similarities t...
Throughout the story, Jason constantly mentions his grandfather's Omega Seamaster De Ville. To me, it seems like the watch becomes a barrier between his childhood and the adult world, and I think his interactions with the watch reveal a lot about his struggle to come of age and maturity. Part of what I think is interesting is how the Omega is framed as a reward for being mature enough. Jason’s dad is "grave as grave" when he gives it to him, calling it a "sign of an excellent watch" (Mitchell 16) because of its thinness and elegance, unlike the "plastic tubs" other teenagers wear. Even though he’s proud of it, he’s terrified of it. He balances a coin on the hiding place just to make sure no one has touched it. He is mortified when he breaks it playing British Bulldogs, and spends a year keeping it secret and trying to find a replacement. Jason’s decision to return Ross Wilcox’s wallet, despite knowing the money inside could buy back his Omega, is reall...